A subcontractor gave us a bid. He started work but did not finish. He is now billed us for double the amount.

2 weeks ago

I am a general contractor for a home owner. We hired a subcontractor (plumber) who provided us with a bid proposal. He started the work but did not finish. He is now invoicing us for more than double the amount.
we had to bring in another plumber to fix the problems and complete the work. We are not disputing we owe him something, but we see no grounds for him to more than doubling his price. Is he able to file a lien on the property based on this basic information?
And our we able to back charge him for damage to the property and paying a new plumber to fix and complete this work?

Additional info about this contractor
Project Role: General Contractor
Project Type: Residential
Owner The Storrs Law Firm
18 reviews

The plumber can file a lien for what he claims is owed. It sounds like if he does so, it could be overstated, and that could lead to some defenses against the lien.

Is he claiming that he had to perform extra work, or changed work warranting an increase in his subcontract amount? That is the first issue. Otherwise, he should be bound to his bid amount.

As far as back charges, yes, you should assert back charges for costs incurred to complete or correct the plumbers work. If he simply abandoned the project, you have every right to assert those charges. He may argue that he stopped working because he had not been paid, which opens up another issue.

Hopefully this summary will guide you, but you need to consult your counsel about this matter.

Disclaimer: This forum is not a secure form of communication. Use of this forum to contact Richard J. Storrs or the Storrs Law Firm does not create an attorney-client relationship. No attorney client relationship exists with Richard J. Storrs or the Storrs Law Firm in the absence of a signed engagement letter. By use of this forum, you acknowledge that we may review any information transmitted and that this review does not preclude Richard J. Storrs or the Storrs Law Firm from representing another client directly adverse to you, even in a matter where that information could and will be used against you. The content of this response is provided for general information and does not constitute legal advice. Legal advice must be based on our complete understanding of the facts and circumstances of your particular issue, and you should seek the assistance of licensed and competent legal counsel for specific legal advice. Because case results depend on a variety of factors unique to each case, case results do not guarantee or predict a result in any future case. Richard Storrs is admitted to practice in the State of Georgia, and is not licensed in other states. Thank you.
Your answer or comment:
Are you a Registered Expert?
You are not logged in and will be posting
anonymously. Log in Now
Get answers from construction attorneys and payment experts
120 Character Limit