Home>Levelset Community>Legal Help>Can a roofing contractor file a mechanics lien on a homeowner in Texas, if the roof he replaced has failed two inspections

Can a roofing contractor file a mechanics lien on a homeowner in Texas, if the roof he replaced has failed two inspections

We had to have our flat roof redone after damage from a hurricane.e We haven't paid for the roof due to fact the new roof leaked throughout the house day after it was done & the damages from the leaking. They charged us for the lien but never served us papers. Won't come back to fix problems

1 reply

Oct 29, 2018

I'm sorry to hear about that. First, it's worth noting that regardless of whether a mechanics lien would ultimately be valid if challenged, a lien filing could still occur. County recorders' offices rarely have the ability or the resources to investigate each claim for its validity. Of course, if a mechanics lien is filed, the owner will have an opportunity to challenge that lien filing, though such a challenge would come via legal action. Further, it's worth noting that a question of workmanship also won't prevent a mechanics lien - though, in a lien proceeding, workmanship would very likely be taken into account when determining what amounts are owed, if any. In a situation where work was faulty, failed inspection, and required repair - a court may very well determine that full payment isn't owed for the work provided. But, as mentioned above, challenging the lien would likely require legal action - and thus, consulting with a local construction attorney would be helpful. They will be able to look at the relevant documentation and other information to determine how best to move forward in challenging a lien - if one was filed. If a claimant merely sent a warning of a lien or otherwise did not file a lien, a demand letter from an attorney threatening legal action could be effective to ward off an improper lien claim. Finally, if a lien was filed but the papers were not properly served, that too could serve as grounds for discharge of the lien claim. This article should be helpful: A Mechanics Lien Was Filed on My Property – What Do I Do Now?

0 people found this helpful

Helpful

Still looking for the right answer? Ask me your question!

Add your answer or comment

Not the answer you were looking for? Check out other Mechanics Lien topics or ask your own question

Get free advice

Get free advice from Construction Attorneys in your state. Questions are anonymous and answered within a day or two